The Court of Appeal has set aside a death sentence and acquitted the man who received it, holding that failures in the police investigation left the conviction unsafe and that the raid behind it appeared to have been carried out “for mockery”.
A two-judge bench of Justices Amal Ranaraja and Dr Sumudu Premachandra allowed the appeal, finding that the prosecution had failed to establish the essential elements of the case beyond reasonable doubt, the Daily Mirror reported.
The case
The accused, Wasantha Wijaya Kumara Yatawara, known as “Bunga”, had been convicted by the Kandy High Court on two counts of possessing and trafficking 236.3 grammes of heroin, following a raid conducted near a leading school in Kandy on 5 May 2021. He was sentenced to death on 9 September 2024.
What the court found wrong with the raid
The judgment turns on the conduct of the officers, and in particular on record-keeping.
The principal investigating officer, Sub-Inspector H. H. Madushan, had not taken his police pocket notebook when leaving for the operation, and failed to record several crucial events — including the handling and custody of the seized heroin. The officer had reportedly conducted around 400 drug-related raids.
The court held that keeping contemporaneous notes is a fundamental requirement of police duty, and that the failure to record important events raised serious doubt about whether the raid had taken place in the manner the prosecution described.
The bench identified further problems:
- significant contradictions between the evidence of the two principal police witnesses about the circumstances of the arrest and the search;
- the failure to weigh and seal the seized heroin immediately at the scene, despite the police team having the sealing equipment with them.
Taken together with the unexplained delay and the absence of proper records, the court held, these created serious doubts about the integrity of the production — the drugs themselves as an exhibit — and about the prosecution’s version of events.
Why this matters beyond one case
The ruling is an appellate court finding that a capital narcotics conviction collapsed on procedure rather than on any dispute about whether the drugs existed. The specific failures it names — no pocket notebook, no contemporaneous record of custody, no immediate weighing and sealing — are routine steps in narcotics work, and the court treated their absence as enough to make the chain of custody unprovable.
Sri Lanka retains the death penalty in law for trafficking offences but has not carried out an execution since 1976, and sentences of death are in practice served as indefinite imprisonment.
Not reported
The filing does not give the date of the Court of Appeal judgment or its case number, say how long Yatawara spent on death row before the appeal was decided, or state whether the Attorney General intends to seek leave to appeal to the Supreme Court. It does not say whether any disciplinary or other action has followed against the officers whose evidence the court criticised, or name the officer-in-charge of the Kandy Police Narcotics Division whose raid was described as conducted “for mockery”.
A note on attribution: the Daily Mirror’s account at one point attributes the findings on record-keeping to “the High Court” while describing the Court of Appeal’s judgment. As the High Court was the court that convicted and sentenced him, the findings quashing that conviction are the Court of Appeal’s, and are reported as such here.
Sourcing
Single-source. The Daily Mirror, 17 November, 10.13 a.m. Colombo time. A search of other verified newsrooms returned no second account of this judgment — results were dominated by unrelated narcotics appeals, including one in which the Court of Appeal upheld death sentences in a 152kg heroin case, which is a different matter entirely. The NewsFirst payload and the Hiru rail carried nothing on it, and Ada Derana remained unreachable behind an HTTP 403 block.