Update: the transfer has been carried out

The handover the court was told would take place on Tuesday evening has happened. Criminal Investigation Department officers took Salley from the National Hospital to the CID at around 6:30 p.m., Hiru News reported.

The same report puts his stay in Ward 42 at 119 days — which resolves, in Hiru’s favour, the ambiguity noted at the foot of this article over what that figure measured. Hiru uses it consistently for the length of the hospital admission, not for the delay to the investigation.

Hiru also reports that when the case was called before the Colombo Fort Magistrate’s Court on Tuesday, Additional Solicitor General Dilipa Peiris told the court that authorities intended to place Salley back under detention custody — indicating the detention-order regime, rather than remand, is the basis on which he is now held.

Update: a full account of the hearing, and a dispute over a phone password

A longer NewsFirst account of the proceedings answers most of the questions left open below, and shows the hearing was considerably sharper than the first filings suggested.

The medical report is dated 28 September and was signed by all ten doctors. It sets out six requirements for Salley’s care after discharge: that prescribed medication be given on time, that he be kept in a suitable environment and under medical supervision, that he attend clinic follow-ups, that he be treated if allergic reactions occur, and that he be referred to the cardiology unit if the cardiac device implanted in him malfunctions. He was in Ward 42 of the National Hospital. Hiru News independently reports the same report date, the same six observations and the same ward.

Nine of the ten doctors appeared in open court. Hospital Director Dr. Sampath Indika Kumara attended with consultants Gamini Galappaththi (cardiology), N.M. Perera, Yamuna Senadheera and Varuni Samaranayake (physicians), Nalinda Herath (nutrition), Anuprabha Wickremesinghe (psychiatry), Susith Amarasinghe (cardiac electrophysiology), Mahen Kothalawala (microbiology) and Asanga Gunathilaka (dental surgery). Consultant Dermatologist Dr. Janaka Akarawita was overseas and did not attend.

The five-versus-ten question is settled

The discrepancy flagged below is resolved: the report that went to court was signed by all ten doctors, and the court summoned all ten. Nothing in either filing explains the five-member panel described in September.

The Attorney General’s Department now appears for the doctors it once accused

Additional Solicitor General Dileepa Peiris told the court he appeared for the doctors because they are government officials — and said plainly that this had not been the original plan. The doctors “had been advised to obtain private legal representation,” he said, and he appeared for them only after they accepted on Monday that Salley could be discharged.

That is a notable turn. As reported below, the prosecution had earlier described Salley’s admission to court as a “medical conspiracy”. Defence counsel made the point directly: “Previously, the complainant itself described these doctors as conspirators before this court. Today, the same side appears on behalf of those doctors.”

The password

The sharpest exchange concerned Salley’s mobile phone. Peiris told the court that Salley had filed a Court of Appeal case supported by 46 documents running to 9,700 pages and a 247-page affidavit — “He was able to do all of that. However, he still claims he cannot remember the password to his mobile phone.” He said the defence position was that Salley changed the password every three days.

Peiris also told the court the medical condition “arose due to his own genetic condition rather than external causes” and was “aggravated by a self-imposed fast”, said Salley had access to the Army Hospital where treatment is free, and added that he “had not even cleaned his ears or brushed his teeth”.

President’s Counsel Shavindra Fernando, appearing for Salley, objected: “Please do not make such derogatory remarks. Address the court in an appropriate manner.”

Peiris went on to say the victims “appear to have been forgotten”, that Salley “did not simply become ill; he was made ill”, and that a doctor who is a relative of Salley and lives in Australia “has been involved in this matter” — adding that the department had been prepared to disclose details but would not pursue the issue now that the doctors had cleared him for discharge. He said Salley had “delayed this investigation for 119 days”.

The magistrate asked whether specialist methods could be used to obtain access to the phone. Peiris replied that appropriate steps would be taken if access could not be obtained through available local mechanisms.

The defence says it has not been given the medical reports

Fernando told the court the defence had requested the medical reports and had not received any of them. He said Tuesday’s hearing was called on a motion filed by the CID of which the defence was not informed — “It was concealed from us… There cannot be one law for the prosecution and another for the defence” — and that the defence still had no medical report on its own client’s condition.

On the password, he said no statement had been recorded from Salley about it, that he had been asked while in hospital, and that three possible passwords were provided in writing at that time. He added: “The real conspirators in this investigation are within the complainant’s side.”

One figure to treat with care

Both the Attorney General’s Department and Hiru use 119 days, but for different things: Hiru reports it as the length of Salley’s treatment at the National Hospital, while Peiris used it in court for the time the investigation had been delayed. Counted back from Tuesday, 119 days reaches 9 June — two days after the 7 June admission date previously reported. Neither outlet reconciles the count.

Former State Intelligence Service director retired Major General Suresh Salley can be discharged from the National Hospital in Colombo and will be returned to Criminal Investigation Department custody, the Fort Magistrate’s Court was told on Tuesday — ending a hospital stay that has run since early June.

A ten-member medical committee of National Hospital doctors informed Magistrate Pasan Amarasena that Salley’s condition is suitable for release from hospital care, the Daily Mirror reported. Additional Solicitor General Dileepa Peiris then told the court Salley would be taken back into CID custody.

NewsFirst reported the Attorney General informed court that the handover would take place on Tuesday evening, following the discharge.

How the detention has run

Salley was arrested on 25 February and held under a 90-day detention order for questioning as part of an ongoing investigation. He was admitted to the National Hospital on 7 June after developing health complications and has remained under medical care since — just under four months.

Authorities had previously told the court that the prolonged hospitalisation was obstructing the inquiry, making it difficult to record statements. A further 90-day detention order was issued against him on 25 August to allow investigators to continue.

This was the hearing the court ordered a week ago

Tuesday’s appearance is the one the court set up on 2 October, when Magistrate Amarasena ordered 10 doctors from Salley’s medical board to appear before him on 6 October after the CID noted that the board’s earlier recommendation — that he remain admitted until 28 September — had lapsed.

That order has now produced an answer. It also partly settles a discrepancy LankaNewz flagged at the time: the board appointed in September was described in earlier reporting as a five-member panel, while the body that reported to court on Tuesday is described by the Daily Mirror as a ten-member committee, consistent with the number of doctors summoned. Neither outlet explains how the panel grew.

Salley is being investigated in connection with the Easter Sunday attacks. Earlier in the proceedings the prosecution told the court it regarded his admission as a “medical conspiracy”, and the National Hospital’s director was placed under notice to explain a failure to produce records.

Not reported

What the medical committee found — answered: a report dated 28 September setting out six care requirements, signed by all ten doctors. Whether any member dissented — effectively answered: the report carries all ten signatures, though no filing addresses dissent in terms. Why the panel’s composition differs from the five-member board named in September — still unexplained, but the body that reported to court is confirmed as ten. No comment from his legal team — answered: President’s Counsel Shavindra Fernando made extensive submissions, set out above.

Still open: whether the existing detention order has time left to run, when Salley is next due in court, and whether the court made any order on the defence’s complaint that it has not been served with the medical reports or notified of the CID’s motion. Neither filing says what the Court of Appeal case referred to by the Attorney General’s Department concerns, or what became of the allegation involving a doctor in Australia now that the department has said it will not pursue it. Nothing is reported on whether investigators have since obtained access to the phone.