The Indian government has told India’s Supreme Court that it has no intention of reopening the 1974 and 1976 agreements governing Katchatheevu and fishing rights in the Palk Strait, citing the importance of its relationship with Sri Lanka, Hiru News reported.
The submissions were made by Attorney General R. Venkataramani before a bench of Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva, hearing long-pending petitions that challenge the arrangements.
The court’s direction to fishermen
The same bench directed Indian fishermen not to cross into Sri Lankan waters near Katchatheevu while fishing, NewsFirst reported, and stressed the need for greater awareness among Tamil Nadu fishermen about where the maritime boundary runs.
Venkataramani submitted that fishermen need to be sensitised against crossing the international boundary, and that the Tamil Nadu state government also has a part in the matter. He told the court that concerns about Indian fishermen are being pursued through diplomatic channels, and that India cannot compel Sri Lanka to accept or comply with its position.
What is being challenged
The petitions attack two separate instruments: the 1974 bilateral agreement under which Katchatheevu was recognised as lying on the Sri Lankan side of the maritime boundary, and the 1976 pact restricting Indian fishermen from fishing in Sri Lankan waters.
NewsFirst reports the petitions before the court as having been filed by the AIADMK and the DMK Fishermen’s Wing, seeking the return of Katchatheevu to India. Hiru identifies the lead matter as A.K. Selvaraj v. Union of India, in which Senior Advocate P. Wilson appeared for the petitioners and argued that the 1974 agreement involved a transfer of territory and therefore required an amendment to Schedule I of the Indian Constitution. Wilson also raised repeated arrests of and alleged attacks on Indian fishermen.
The petitions have been pending since 2008. They argue that the arrangements damage the livelihoods and security of Tamil Nadu fishermen.
What the court did not decide
The bench made no ruling on the constitutional or legal validity of either agreement. Both challenges remain pending, and the case has been listed for further hearing in February 2027.
During the hearing, Justice Sanjay Kumar observed that Sri Lankan environmental practices might explain the movement of fish towards Sri Lankan waters — a point raised against the petitioners’ account of why Tamil Nadu boats cross. Hiru reports depletion of fish stocks on the Indian side as the driver of the crossings.
What was said in court
A later Daily Mirror report, carrying a New Indian Express account of the same hearing, sets out the exchanges and establishes that the court’s direction to fishermen was an oral observation, not a written order.
Asked by Justice Kumar whether New Delhi was discussing the agreements with Colombo — “Are you talking to them about the treaty?” — Venkataramani replied: “The government doesn’t want to get into it. They entered into it initially but then dropped it at some point of time.” He added that India does not want to spoil what he called its excellent relationship with Sri Lanka.
On why boats cross, the Attorney General pointed to pollution on the Indian side: “We are polluting our seas. Fishermen are told not to go into territorial waters of Sri Lanka, [but] they still venture there.” Prashanto Chandra Sen, Additional Advocate General for Tamil Nadu, disputed that, saying the fishermen do not pollute the water bodies. Additional Advocate General Haripriya argued the matter should be settled by the union government with Sri Lanka directly.
Justice Kumar said something needed to be done about the arrests and that fishermen must be “sensitised to not go beyond a particular point.”
Twenty Indian fishermen are currently in Sri Lankan custody, according to the Daily Mirror report, which cites a recent letter from Tamil Nadu Chief Minister C. Joseph Vijay to the centre urging steps towards their early release.
The attribution of the environmental point differs between filings. Hiru places an observation about Sri Lankan environmental practices and the movement of fish with Justice Kumar; the Daily Mirror account places the pollution argument with the Attorney General and locates the pollution on the Indian side. The two may be separate remarks made during the same hearing.
A note on the proceedings
This is a case in India’s Supreme Court, brought by Indian petitioners against the Union of India. Sri Lanka is not a party to it, and no Sri Lankan court is involved. The Sri Lankan government’s position, stated repeatedly in past years, has been that the matter was settled by the 1974 agreement.
The island’s name is rendered variously across the filings — Katchatheevu, Kachchativu and Kachchatheevu. This report uses the spelling carried in the body text of both sources.
A note on the date
This report originally described the hearing as having taken place on Wednesday 7 October, the day the Sri Lankan filings appeared. The New Indian Express account carried by the Daily Mirror places it on Tuesday, 6 October, with the Sri Lankan newsrooms reporting it the following day. The Indian paper is the closer source to the court’s calendar, and the earlier date has been adopted here.
Update, 8 October: Colombo responds
Sri Lanka’s Fisheries, Aquatic and Marine Resources Minister Ramalingam Chandrasekar has welcomed the Indian court’s observations, the Daily Mirror reported on Thursday — the first Sri Lankan government response to the hearing.
Chandrasekar said the observation was significant because Sri Lanka has consistently raised the effect of illegal and destructive fishing by foreign vessels on the country’s marine resources and on livelihoods in the Northern Province. Unauthorised entry into Sri Lankan waters, and in particular methods that damage the seabed, threaten both, he said.
“Protecting Sri Lanka’s marine resources and marine environment is a primary responsibility of our government. We have consistently voiced our objections regarding illegal and destructive fishing activities occurring within our territorial waters.”
On the agreements themselves the Minister did not move from Colombo’s long-standing position. He described the 1974 agreement on Katchatheevu and the 1976 understandings on maritime boundaries and fishing as resting on a long-standing diplomatic understanding between the two countries, and said: “Sri Lanka’s position on this matter is clear.”
He called for sustainable solutions through continued dialogue and diplomatic channels, balancing the livelihoods of fishing communities on both sides against the need to protect marine resources.
The Daily Mirror also reports that Justice Sanjay Kumar referred during the hearing to the sense of social responsibility he had observed among Sri Lankans on environmental protection, including the keeping of public and coastal areas clean — consistent with the environmental observation Hiru attributed to him and noted above.
A second filing on the Minister’s statement, 9 October
Hiru News filed its own account of the same ministerial statement on Friday, reporting it from a media release issued by the Ministry. It adds the Minister’s own words on the boundary point:
“We welcome the observation made by the Supreme Court of India on the need to educate Tamil Nadu fishermen to refrain from unlawfully entering Sri Lankan territorial waters.
“Foreign fishing vessels entering Sri Lankan waters illegally, especially those using destructive fishing methods that damage the seabed, severely impact the livelihoods of Northern Province fishermen as well as our ocean resources.”
The release also restates the government’s position on the treaties directly: the 1974 agreement on Katchatheevu and the 1976 agreements on maritime boundaries and fishing are “rooted in long-standing diplomatic understandings between the two nations,” and “Sri Lanka’s position on this matter remains clear.”
Hiru’s account places the emphasis on informing Tamil Nadu fishermen against entering Sri Lankan territorial waters, and says the judge’s remarks on Sri Lankan environmental practice were made from a previous visit to Sri Lanka — a detail the Daily Mirror account does not carry. It also records the Ministry noting the judge’s remarks on the state of fish stocks in Sri Lankan waters.
Two discrepancies to record. Hiru describes the Indian Supreme Court bench as led by Justice Sanjiv Khanna. The three earlier filings — Hiru’s own 7 October report, NewsFirst and the Daily Mirror — all give the bench as Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva, and the Daily Mirror’s New Indian Express account attributes the exchanges in court to Justice Kumar. The earlier and better-corroborated rendering is retained above. Hiru also renders the Minister’s portfolio as Fisheries, Aquatic and Ocean Resources, where the Daily Mirror gives Fisheries, Aquatic and Marine Resources.
Update, 10 October: a fourth newsroom, and the detentions running alongside the case
Tamil Guardian has filed its own account of the hearing, reporting the Attorney General’s refusal to reopen the agreements in the same terms as the Sri Lankan filings — the “excellent relationship” with Colombo, the pollution argument, Justice Kumar’s remark on sensitising fishermen, the 1974 and 1976 instruments, the petitions pending since 2008, P. Wilson’s constitutional-amendment argument, and the February 2027 return date. It adds no fact the four earlier filings lack, and the accounts agree throughout.
It frames the court’s direction slightly differently, as telling both New Delhi and Tamil Nadu to make fishermen aware of where the maritime boundary runs — consistent with Venkataramani’s submission, recorded above, that the Tamil Nadu state government also has a part in the matter.
Its filing is dated 10 October, four days after the hearing.
What the account usefully places alongside the case is the enforcement happening while it remains pending. Tamil Guardian notes that the Sri Lankan navy detained nine Indian fishermen off Delft Island this month, and that Rameshwaram fishermen have since staged an indefinite strike over the detentions. It also records the longer-standing complaint of Tamil fishermen in the Northern Province that Indian bottom trawlers destroy their nets and deplete stocks — the grievance the Fisheries Minister invoked in welcoming the court’s observation.
The twenty Indian fishermen in Sri Lankan custody reported by the Daily Mirror, and the nine detained off Delft, are separate figures from separate filings, and no account reconciles them.
Not reported
No filing carries a response from the Sri Lankan government, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs or the Sri Lanka Navy to the submissions. — answered in part: the Fisheries Minister responded on 8 October, above. No response has been reported from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs or the Sri Lanka Navy. None says how the court’s direction to fishermen is to be enforced, or whether it binds the Tamil Nadu government to any particular action.
The Minister’s statement does not address the twenty Indian fishermen in Sri Lankan custody, the Tamil Nadu Chief Minister’s letter, or whether Colombo intends any approach to New Delhi arising from the hearing.
Neither says what form it takes as an order — answered: the Daily Mirror account establishes it was an oral observation from the bench, not a written order. No report gives the number of Indian fishermen currently in Sri Lankan custody, or says whether the Indian government’s position was stated in a written affidavit or only orally through the Attorney General. — answered: twenty, per the Tamil Nadu Chief Minister’s letter as reported by the Daily Mirror; and the Attorney General’s position was put orally in open court.
Still unreported: whether the twenty are held on fisheries charges or under other provisions, and whether Colombo has received or responded to any approach arising from the Chief Minister’s letter.
Sources: Hiru News, NewsFirst, Daily Mirror, Daily Mirror — Fisheries Minister’s response, Hiru News — Ministry media release, 9 October 2026, Tamil Guardian, 10 October 2026.