A French court has annulled Sotheby’s sale of a Camille Pissarro painting looted by the Nazis and ordered the auction house to help the descendants of its original Jewish owner recover it.
The Paris Judicial Court delivered its judgment on 5 November, CNN reported, citing the ruling.
The work — Darse de pêche et bassin Duquesne, Dieppe, après-midi ensoleillée, or “Fishing dock and Duquesne basin, Dieppe, sunny afternoon” — fetched £1.2 million (about $1.6 million) when the auction house’s London branch sold it to an anonymous buyer in 2024.
How the painting was lost
Salomon Flavian, a Jewish banker of French and Romanian heritage, bought the 1902 landscape in 1935. When war broke out in September 1939, he had it crated along with dozens of other works and stored at the Westminster Foreign Bank in Paris.
Those crates, the Pissarro among them, were seized by the Nazis in 1941.
Flavian survived the war and was reunited with some of his looted collection. The Pissarro was never returned to the family.
Why the sale was challenged
Flavian appeared in the provenance section of the painting’s listing on Sotheby’s website, because he bought it in 1935. The court noted there was little else on the listing to explain that the work had been looted, beyond a single line stating that it was “being offered for sale pursuant to a settlement between the current owner and heirs of Salomon Flavian.”
Two Flavian descendants had reached an agreement with the seller in 2024. Other descendants, who say they were not party to it, brought the lawsuit — and the court ruled in their favour.
What the court ordered
- The 2024 sale is annulled.
- Sotheby’s must disclose the full identity of the buyer within two months, so the work can be returned to the family.
- If it does not, it faces a penalty of €1,000 (about $1,115) for every further day of delay.
- The Toronto-based Mondex Corporation, a firm specialising in recovering Nazi-looted art, was also ruled against for its role in brokering the 2024 agreement, and ordered to pay the descendants €10,000 (around $11,000).
The responses
The descendants who brought the case said through their law firm, Cabinet Corinne Hershkovitch, that they were “pleased that the Paris Court of Justice has recognized the spoliation of the claimed Pissarro painting and, through this historic ruling, has restored the memory and honor of their father and grandfather.”
Mondex maintains the painting was not looted, saying the British art collector Edward Le Bas owned it from 1939 to the early 1950s. It told CNN the decision “was lacking a detailed analysis of the provenance evidence provided and as such warrants an appeal so that all of the relevant facts can be considered thoroughly.”
Sotheby’s said it respects the judgment on restitution but is “disappointed by this aspect of the decision,” adding that the artwork’s history “is complex” and that it “fully recognise[s] the profound losses suffered by the Flavian family during the Nazi era.” It said a procedural process must be followed for the decision to be enforced in the UK, and that it was reviewing the judgment.
Not reported
The filing does not say whether the anonymous 2024 buyer has been contacted, where the painting is now, whether Sotheby’s or Mondex has formally lodged an appeal, or what the two Flavian descendants who signed the 2024 agreement received under it.
Sourcing note
This account rests on a single newsroom. CNN worked from the court ruling and from statements sent to it directly by Sotheby’s, Mondex and the family’s lawyers; the text of the judgment has not been independently reviewed here. No Sri Lankan verified newsroom had carried the ruling when this article was written, and a search of Al Jazeera returned no filing on it.